Yes, kind of, sort of joking. I knew it would get someone's attention. I completely agree that it's gross but personally, if I had the choice, I would prefer the thumb to a soother. Whenever I have a child here that has one, they get boiled frequently here cuz I find the ones that come from home are so usually full of scummy stuff. That to me is so much grosser than a slobery thumb. Hands can be washed a lot easier. Oh, and to be clear, I am talking about thumb sucking for sleeping. Not that I prefer a 6yo walking around sucking her thumb.